It seems like everyone else in the blogosphere has invited guest bloggers to contribute to their content. When I noticed this trend recently, I liked that idea. This will not only add some variety, but also give me a break once in a while because, like, you know, it’s hard to write all these blogs by yourself when you have to eat, sleep, train and repeat every day. So… although (as usual) I seem to be the last one to the party, I thought I’d join the crowd and invite our first guest blogger to the Burn The Fat Blog, strength coach Charles Staley. I love this article. So simple. So true.
Occam’s Barbell:
Ending Paralysis By Analysis
A Guest Blog by Charles Staley, B.Sc, MSS
Director, Staley Training Systems
www.StaleyTraining.com
* Paraphrased from Wikipedia:
Occam’s razor (sometimes spelled Ockham’s razor) is a principle attributed to the 14th-century English logician and Franciscan friar, William of Ockham. The principle states that the explanation of any phenomenon should make as few assumptions as possible, eliminating those that make no difference in the observable predictions of the explanatory hypothesis or theory. This is often paraphrased as “All other things being equal, the simplest solution is the best.” In other words, when multiple competing theories are equal in other respects, the principle recommends selecting the theory that introduces the fewest assumptions and postulates the fewest entities. It is in this sense that Occam’s razor is usually understood.
What’s that? You’re confused? Here’s a little news-flash: I’m confused too! The only difference between you and I is:
I take action in the face of confusion, and you don’t
In my experience, “paralysis by analysis” is the most common barrier to action, and by extension, successful action. Because after all, analysis is the preface to action- it isn’t action itself.
Analysis can certainly serve a useful purpose, but for many, it’s both a crutch and an excuse for delaying action. Here’s a typical brain-twister that novice lifters often find themselves confronted by:
Should you do 6 sets of 2, or 4 sets of 3?
My advice? Don’t even think about starting a training program until you’ve resolved this critical conundrum, because after all, both options involve 12 reps with the same weight, so obviously if you go down the wrong path, you’ll be screwed, glued, and tattooed.
Another critical decision: should you bike or row for cardio on Tuesdays?
God help you if you should happen to choose the wrong exercise or repetition bracket, or if you stupidly decide to train 3 times a week instead of 4. Because now you’re stuck for the rest of your training career. Too bad you didn’t think that decision through more carefully before you got all irrational and went and wrote yourself a stupid program.
OK, on a more serious note…
I really like the old carpenter’s adage “Measure twice, cut once.” But this philosophy is absurdly over-cautious when applied to training program design. A program isn’t a piece of wood- if you make an error, you have my permission to edit it. Honest.
And don’t even ask me to evaluate your 18-week off-season developmental conditioning cycle, because it’ll make my eyes glaze over faster than last night’s episode of Oprah where that Dr. Oz guy is telling me to do some kinda meditation stuff for stress-reduction.
Because let’s face it- 18 weeks from now, lots of things can happen. You could get sick, or even injured. You might break up with your girlfriend. Or find a girlfriend. Or lose your job. Or join some extremist religion that forbids the use of barbells. Or even more likely than any of the above, you might read some new article or book about some new training program that seems a hell of a lot more interesting than what you’re doing now.
So look: let’s just focus on the here-and-now, and further, let’s focus on the “big rocks:” the stuff that really matters. The rest we can figure out later- maybe next week, maybe next month, but later.
Now obviously some of you are now expecting me to tell you what a big rock is before you can ever touch a weight again, so here are a few examples of big rocks (stuff that matters) and small rocks (stuff that doesn’t matter):
Big Rocks Small Rocks
Squat Heavy: How much? How often? How deep? What kind of squat?
Eat Protein: How much? How often? What kind of protein?
Set Goals: How many? How hard should they be? In writing?
Record Your Training: How? Why? What kind of paper?
Now in most cases, people worry about the small rocks without even getting the big rocks in place- they’ve got the cart before the horse. So look- just squat. In the beginning, you’ll probably do it all wrong, but even that’s a lot better than not squatting. Then, little by little, you’ll figure out how to do it correctly, and guess what- you’re already great progress will get even better!
And eat protein. Don’t worry about how much- just eat a lot. Don’t worry about what kind, we’ll get to that later. Get your big rocks in the jar first, then we’ll worry about the little rocks, and maybe someday we’ll fill the rest of the jar with sand. Maybe.
In Summary:
Action precedes progress; analysis precedes more analysis. Act first, analyze later
It’s easier to go from something to something better, than it is to go from nothing to something
Ever notice how lots of people make great progress doing “stupid” stuff? It’s because they’re doing while you’re not doing. Doing stupid stuff will always beat not doing smart stuff.
That’s it – you’re done. Go squat and eat some protein.
His colleagues call him an iconoclast, a visionary, a rule-breaker. His clients call him “The Secret Weapon” for his ability to see what other coaches miss. Charles calls himself a “geek” who struggled in Phys Ed throughout school. Whatever you call him, Charles’ methods are ahead of their time and quickly produce serious results. His counter-intuitive approach and self-effacing demeanor have lead to appearances on NBC’s The TODAY Show and The CBS Early Show. Currently, Charles competes in Olympic-style weightlifting on the master’s circuit, with a goal of qualifying for the Master’s World Championships.
Learn More About Charles’ training system ( EDT)
www.StaleyTraining.com
Superbly written and oh so factual. Energy focused will always surpass energy wasted. Action is the stimulus for muscle, regardless if your form is right or wrong. You can always learn as your progress but if you wait for the perfect moment it will never come.
Absolutely loved this – it is great! Hit the nail right on the head for me (and others), and the humour – wonderful:-) Not comfortable, but so true! Thanks for this.
If you logon to any bodybuilding forum, you’ll see newbie’s fretting over the minutae around optimal times for whey consumption, critical times for cardio, should it be HIIT/steady state, when to take 5g of Glutamine and when to take 10g etc, and they’ve only been training for a few weeks?The squat message is a fundamental truth – not many beginners like it though!Good work fella!
I love this!! I am a “thinker” therefore I spend a lot of time “thinking” instead of doing. I get stagnated in the planning stage and have difficulty moving into the doing stage. Fortunately, I’m not going from Nothing to Something – I do weight train 3 x’s per week, do cardio 6-7 x’s per week and really try to eat clean and adjust my diet along the way. So, I see my self as being in the “doing something to doing something better” category. But I still think so hard about all of this!! I need to simplify – I like this guys way of thinking!!I’m gonna go think about this for awhile! ha!
WOW. It is so true, I get so caught up with what, how heavy, how long etc that I just put it off when deep down I know that ANY exertion of energy is better than none at all, so sometimes I go to the gym for 10 or 20 mins even when I don’t feel like it and just do something, anything. If you don’t change what your doing nothing will ever change.Motivation is the hardest part, exercise now and worry about what and how and when as you go along! So true.:)
That’s it boys and girls- run, run fast. Who cares if you’re on the wrong road, you can later spend a lot more time and energy trying to figure out how to get on the right road. Look, I agree that action is key to success in anything. But I dread all those who dismiss analysis as some secondary step. The fact is both are important, EQUALLY important. Goals without action are but mere dreams. Action without analysis/vision is nothing more than a waste of energy. Only when you combine the two do you obtain success. I remember when Bill Gates would rush to get his newest Windows version out to market; “don’t worry about the bugs, we’ll send out patches and fixes later.” Now I know why I switched over to a mac. Best of luck in your training, David G.
Wonderful article, Charles. Now could you please clone yourself a thousand times over and head out to gyms everywhere to help people see the light: I too used to get caught up in the small stuff, like should I do the cable triceps extensions for 12 reps first and then the DB extensions or vice versa, and heaven forbid someone come in between and want to use my weights!Your comments help bring home what I wish I would’ve realized long ago – for the vast majority of us, what really counts is simply time under tension. Period.
Good lord! Great article and really hits the bulls eye for me. There are so many times I’ve over-thought things and became indecisive, confused myself and focused too much on minute details, that I forgot to see the bigger picture and failed to take action and work hard instead.There are A LOT of different nutrition plans and training routines out there, that I sometimes find myself arguing WITH myself on which to follow. Rigidity and indecisiveness is usually my downfall to falling off the wagon. By being more flexible and periodically adjusting my diet and training as it suits me, I find that I’m able to stick to it easier and more consistently, rather than being all monotonously rigid about it. I make better progress by being more flexible and taking action.
OMG! this is great. I was laughing the whole way through. And I spend a lot of time dealing with stupid people in the gym. Their eyes always get a glazed look when I try to take them anywhere near the squat rack. Admittedly I work in an all women’s gym. its even more frustrating than a regular gym. If I could get them to start taking protein I think the sky would fall. .
I just love your common sence.
Hi Tom,
You recently interviewed Joel Marion about his “Cheat Your Way Thin” plan. Since I started out with that plan before I started on this one, and decided this one fit my own profile better, I would have been very interested in your comments/observations about his eating plan – which differs significantly from BFFM. However, I didn’t see any such comments or observations. So, can you please tell us sometime just what you do think of it?
“free for all” cheat days is NOT my preferred approach. I prefer more restrained strategy such as setting a compliance rule (ie, 90% compliance and so on), or a number of weekly free meals with no restrictions on foods, but restraint with calories… and using refeed days with clean food not junk. I dont really have a critique of CYWT, but you can get a sense of my position by reading my interview with joel: http://blog.holygrailbodytransformation.com/?p=232